The Rev. Abel T Stewart |
| 1866-1878 |
The Rev. Daniel Van Pelt |
| 1879-1882 |
The Rev. Thomas Walker Jones |
| 1883-1888 |
The Rev. John Talmadge Bergen |
| 1889-1891 |
The Rev. John M. Vander Meulen |
| 1907-1909 |
The Rev. Edward Niles | 1910-1911 | |
The Rev. August F. Bruske | 1912-1916 | |
The Rev. Peter Paul Cheff | 1918-1924 | |
The Rev. Thomas W. Davidson | 1925-1937 | |
The Rev. Marion de Velder | 1939-1959 | |
The Rev William C. Hilligonds | 1960-1965 | |
The Rev. John R. Walchebach | Associate Pastor | 1964-1966 |
The Rev. Glen O. Peterman | Senior Pastor | 1966-1976 |
The Rev. Marlin Vander Wilt | Associate Pastor | 1971-1976 |
| Interim Pastor | 1976-1978 |
| Co-Pastor | 1978-1982 |
| Senior Pastor | 1982-1983 |
The Rev. Paul R. Fries | Co-Pastor | 1978-1982 |
The Rev. Marchiene Rienstra | Senior Pastor | 1984-1989 |
The Rev. Dennis TeBeest | Associate Pastor | 1985-1989 |
| Senior Pastor | 1989-1997 | |
The Rev. Toni Macon | Associate Pastor | 1989-1990 |
The Rev. Ruth Staal | Associate Pastor | 1991-1996 |
The Rev. Kathryn Davelaar |
| 1998-2007 |
The Rev. Gordon Wiersma |
| 1999- |
| The Rev. Jill Russell | 2008- |
Pastors |